Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Lost in Translation


15 January 

My fifth graders never cease to amuse me.

According to them, not only do I have the chickenpox but I’m also preparing for a trip to the moon.

It’s inevitable that teaching science in a foreign language will lead to some confusion –despite my efforts using miming, drawings, and (attempts at) Nepali to explain the more difficult concepts in the book. At the end of class yesterday, I bounced back and forth between two discussions: one describing the plane ride back to America and the other assuring two boys that there is not, in fact, a tree growing on the moon.

To a passerby, it sounded a bit like this:

“Nope, I’m going on a plane because it’s bigger than a helicopter and can hold more people and all their bags…”
“…nothing can grow on the moon because there is no water or gases for it to live. But people have visited the moon. They travel in a very big spaceship and it takes a long time to get there…”
“…it’s a long flight –almost a whole day –to get to my home. The plane flies very high above the clouds, so it’s hard to see the ground…”
“…no, the men on the moon didn’t cook daal bhaat in their spaceship. They had bags of food that were ready to eat…”
“…you don’t get hungry because you get boxes of food and things to drink on the plane…”

Purnima apparently had been piecing together bits of these two conversations and came up with her own explanation. Her head, which had been buried in her notebook, jolted up in surprise. “Annie Miss! You’re going to the MOON?!”

And with that, the bell rang, marking the beginning of recess and the students rushed from the room like a rocket blasting off from its base.

Hmm. This is one of those lessons that may require further explanation…

No comments:

Post a Comment